Plugins, Reviews & Comparisons

Melodyne 5 – The Best Autotune Plug-In For Garageband

Written By : Andrew Siemon

As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. Additionally, I earn a commission through each purchase made on Amazon, Clickbank, zZounds, Plugin Boutique, Plugin Fox, Thomann, Jam Play, and Punkademic from one of my links.

Celemony’s Melodyne 5 Studio pack is the best pitch correction/auto-tune plug-in for Garageband.

The amount of features included with Melodyne 5 is hard to explain with a few short sentences, which is why this article is so in-depth; I did my best to convey how useful this software has actually been for me.

However, while Melodyne 5 Studio has the most features, I would recommend getting the Editor version from Plugin Boutique to start because it’s the most amount of value for the price.

Also, note that if you want the traditional auto-tune sound and you’re interested strictly in tuning vocals, Antares Auto-Tune Pro (from Plugin Boutique) is a better option. We’ll talk a bit more about this in a second.

Antares Auto-Tune Pro Versus Celemony’s Melodyne 5 – Studio

Antares Auto-Tune and Celemony's Melodyne 5 - Best Pitch Correction Plugin for Garageband

If you’re looking into Auto-Tune, you may wonder what the difference is between Melodyne 5 and Antares’ Auto-Tune Pro and whether you should choose one or the other.

Simply put, if you’re looking to only pitch-correct and auto-tune vocals, Antares Auto-Tune Pro is the better option, but if you want a full-featured audio editing tool, then Celemony’s Melodyne 5 – Studio is superior.

I own both of these software and like I said in my article on the best accessories for Garageband, I prefer using Melodyne 5 simply because it’s more versatile and can be used for more than just vocals.

Melodyne 5 can be used for all types of audio, including guitar, piano, and pretty much any other instrument you could possibly imagine.

Features of Melodyne 4 Studio

How To Start

To get started, you just have to hit the ‘Transfer’ button in Melodyne’s interface and then hit play on the vocals. From here, Melodyne will load the track into the interface for editing.


Easy-To-Understand Blob/Wave Format

After you’ve printed the audio recording into Melodyne 4, the software portrays it as “blobs” and wavy-lines.

The blob represents the note, the volume, and the duration of the vocal track.

The wavy-lines portray the direction and flow of the pitch.

Using the plug-in’s Main Tool, you can adjust the positioning of the notes which ultimately changes the pitch completely, according to either a diatonic key signature, the chromatic scale, or randomly.

By randomly, I mean that you can adjust the pitch of the note in such a way where it’s not connected to any scale.

Melodyne Algorithms

Melodyne has different algorithms for different types of audio, including an algorithm for entire mixes such as every instrument collectively; algorithms for noise, percussive instruments, vocals, and also for instruments like the bass and electric guitar.

These different algorithms determine how the audio signal will be shown in the interface as well as how it’ll be interpreted by the software.

There are three main algorithms:

1) Melodic and Polyphonic: Melodic and Polyphonic allow for the adjustment of notes and pitch, including various parameters like amplitude (volume), vibrato, etc.

2) Percussive: The Percussive algorithm gives you the ability to adjust the note in terms of its timing, which is great for drums, drum loops, and other percussive instruments, or even noisy instruments that don’t have a particular pitch.

In other words, the percussive algorithms allow you to adjust the timing, and due to the combined use of the melodic and polyphonic, also the pitch of the note, even though the sound it’s adjusting isn’t a melodic instrument, ie, guitar versus a snare drum.

3) Universal: The universal algorithm is used for stretching the note across a certain amount of time and also transposing mixes and other instruments.

The combined functions of all of the aforementioned algorithms allow for broad and subtle changes across several different parameters. For example, you can actually stretch out a note sung by a singer.

This isn’t possible to do in Garageband using the default pitch-correction plug-in unless you use Melodyne, another plug-in, or nuanced tactics that are more time-consuming.

Pitch Editing Software

Melodyne is capable of pitch editing on a number of different levels, including the pitch center and pitch modulation (also known as vibrato).

Using an example to explain what I mean, it’s possible to adjust the amount of vibrato within a particular note.

Down to the very specific pitch fluctuation of the note, you can determine how much the pitch is drifting away from the note’s center.

If there’s too much vibrato and just a part of it is off-key, you can pull it more toward the center, or, you could make the vibrato much stronger.

Not only can you adjust the amount of vibrato but also the general direction of the pitch.

It’s possible to adjust the pitch of notes on a very subtle level, for instance, toward the correct pitch rather than exactly on point.

How To Do It

You do this by selecting the note using the Pitch Modulation tool, and then dragging and dropping it to where you want it to go based on its location in the grid.

The lines will flip up and down or flatten out depending on what tool you use and how you use it.

If you’ve ever used the auto-tune/pitch-correction plug-in in Garageband (my guide on this), you’ll know that it doesn’t allow for very small and subtle changes.

Melodyne 4 makes up for that because you can actually push one-note individually, rather than all of them collectively as is the case using Garageband’s default plug-in.

This allows for WAY more customization.

What makes Melodyne amazing is that it’s capable of changing the pitch of notes while also retaining its natural quality.

Explained in another way, it’s not going to change the “human quality” of the sound. I was actually pleasantly surprised by Melodyne’s ability to change the pitch without noticeably altering its natural sound, and I can’t emphasize this enough.

For instance, if a vocalist has sung a particular part and you want to move it up a Major Third for the sake of harmonization, it’ll sound just as good using Melodyne.

It really does a tremendous job of adjusting the pitch without making it sound bad or weird.

Snap To Grid For Time Quantizing And Pitch Correction

Like I mentioned above, in addition to adjusting the notes individually, it also has the capability to make sweeping changes across the board, rather than adjusting each note on a case-by-case basis.

What I mean by this, is that you can snap all the notes to the grid according to a particular key, similar to how it’s done in Garageband.

How To Do It

You do this by selecting “Edit,” in the tool-bar, and then “Quantization Macros,” and then either “Correct Pitch” or “Quantize Time.”

You can snap it to the grid based on a particular key signature, as well as make sweeping changes to the pitch drift and pitch center.

Furthermore, you can change the pitch of note according to a particular scale if you want, for instance, the chromatic scale or another diatonic scale such as the A Major Scale.

Polyphonic (Multiple-Note) Editing

While Melodyne has a lot of impressive features, its ability to adjust the pitch of chords and other notes played together really stands out in my opinion.

For this, you would want to use the “Polyphonic” algorithm, which is used for adjusting notes played harmonically (all at the same time).

Melodyne, however, will use its Automatic detection system to figure out what algorithm is necessary. But it doesn’t hurt to select the proper algorithm as a preventative measure.

In the image you can see below, I took one of Garageband’s Apple Loops – an acoustic guitar playing chords – and you can see that Melodyne used the Polyphonic algorithm to literally pull the audio apart so that you can see each note played individually.

Because of this, you can actually change the pitch of each part of the strum. It’s honestly pretty amazing.

You could use this feature for guitar or piano chords, or really any instrument that’s capable of harmonies.

How To Do This

It’s done the same way as other forms of editing. You just have to use the Transfer button to print the audio into Melodyne, and the software should automatically pick up on what algorithm is necessary for editing.

Changing The Timing

The notes in Melodyne can be edited in a number of ways, including by shortening or lengthening, moved forwards or backward, or quantized according to a grid.

This is also possible using the Flex Timing option in Garageband (my tutorial), but Melodyne can adjust minor details more specifically and in a more nuanced fashion.

The specificity of Melodyne is more in-depth than the Flex Time function. For instance, you can correct very specific errors and transients.

How To Do This

It’s really fairly intuitive. Just use the Main Tool to pull the notes toward whatever grid-line that you want.

Additionally, you can use the time quantization tool that I mentioned above. You go into the top toolbar, select “Edit,” and then “Quantization Macros,” and then “Quantize Time.”

Tempo Editing

A cool additional feature of the plug-in is that it can actually detect the tempo of your song, that way you can create a quantization grid that works perfectly with the tempo of the song.

Furthermore, you can generate a click track afterward if you want to.

If you’re familiar with Garageband, you’ll know that the time editing function is perhaps the most limited aspect of the DAW.

For instance, you can’t change the timing and tempo of one track without adjusting the timing and tempo of the rest of the music (although, there are weird and time-consuming ways of getting around this as I’ve explored before).

Melodyne allows you do to make these changes, either for editing or creative purposes.

How To Do This

In the image you can see above, I’ve pointed out the number tempo system that you can click on and make changes from there.

Volume Editing

Garageband comes with the ability to adjust the velocity, strength, and volume of MIDI notes, but the same thing can’t be said for audio recordings, whether it be a guitar, bass guitar, or vocals.

Although, of course, you can adjust the volume but only on the entire track, unless you use automation.

Melodyne allows you to adjust the amplitude and volume of particular notes and sections of the audio recording.

Undesirable fluctuations in volume can be adjusted after the fact, without the use of an additional plug-in such as a compressor or noise gate, which would typically adjust ALL of the notes, rather than one individual note.

This has other added benefits, including the ability to adjust other undesirable sounds in a recording, such as breathing sounds or some kind of sound in the background.

How To Do This

Similar to other functions, you just have to select the right tool in the top-center toolbar.

Multi-Tracking Capability

Using the note editor, it’s possible to look at as many tracks as you want at the same time for the sake of reference or editing, depending on what you want.

As a result, it’s a lot easier to make adjustments and changes while also seeing what everything looks like in the context of the entire mix.

How To Do This

Click on the fader option of the top-left side of the toolbar. This will bring up the tracks as I’ve shown in the image above.

Tempo Detection

Melodyne comes with an intelligent algorithm that’s able to comprehend time signatures and tempos, including whether or not they’ve changed on a very subtle or major level.

I said already that it has the ability to create a click-track, but what’s special about it is that it can go along with the performers rather than the other way around.

But in the case of this plug-in, you can actually create a click-track that will change according to the musician’s performance, while at the same time, still being able to look at how the music looks in a typical DAW-grid that uses the number of beats as a unit of measurement.

Furthermore, you can adjust wandering tempo changes without eliminating the minor alterations in dynamics, which is useful for a live performance, for example.

A lot of Garageband users also want the ability to adjust tempo and synchronize different recordings together, which isn’t usually possible using the default DAW plug-ins, however, Melodyne makes it possible to do this.

Relatively Easy-To-Use Interface

When it comes to using music production/recording software and equipment, the number of controls, screens, and settings, can be quite daunting. This is one reason I recommend producers get PianoForAll (from their site) for learning the keyboard, the foundation on which every MIDI keyboard is created.

In Melodyne’s case, they’ve done a decent job of making a comprehensible interface, similar to Garageband. Garageband users know that its interface is one of the reasons why it’s such a great DAW to start out with, so we know the value of a simple workspace.

With that said, I would say that Melodyne’s interface isn’t quite as intuitive as Garageband. In fact, this is my primary criticism of the plug-in thus far.

But like any tool, it’s going to take some work to grow accustomed to it.

Keyboard Shortcuts

An added feature that some may like is the ability to create custom keyboard shortcuts. Frankly, I’m not much for making these kinds of changes, but other people might.

How To Do This

Go into Settings, select “Preferences,” and then “Shortcuts.”

Stand-Alone Mode and Plug-In Interface

You also have the option to use Melodyne as its own piece of software, or as a plug-in that comes up directly in Garageband.

The stand-alone version looks like what you can see in the image below:

How To Do This

To bring up the stand-alone version of the plug-in, you just have to open it up as a typical application at the bottom of your toolbar. You might have to search for it in your application menu first.

Melodyne 4 Buying Guide

The Melodyne 4 plug-in comes in 4 different packages, Essential, Assistant, Editor, and Studio, with Essential being the cheapest and Studio as the most expensive.

Frankly, I would totally avoid getting the Melodyne 4 Essential, because it’s the bare-bones version of the plug-in and you won’t be satisfied with it. As I already mentioned above, the most amount of value for the price is Melodyne 5 – Editor (from Plugin Boutique), however, the Studio version (also on Plugin Boutique) is the whole package that includes EVERYTHING in all of its holy entirety.

Thankfully, you can actually upgrade each one with a smaller fee, so if you’ve started out with the Assistant plug-in, you can pay the difference and move on to the more superior version.

Differences Between Each Version Of Melodyne

The ‘x’ on the right-hand side of the chart determines that the version of the software does have the capabilities listed on the left-hand side.

***These Charts Are Taken From Celemony’s Website

Access them directly at this link here.

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is Melodyne-Differences-2-Edited.jpg

Cons And Important Things To Consider

1) Don’t Use Command + Z Function

When you have the plug-in open in Garageband, be careful not to use the (Command + Z) function to undo changes in Melodyne.

For whatever reason, they didn’t program the plug-in so that you could use the same Command function to undo changes.

What will end up happening is that Garageband might just shut down the plug-in and you’ll lose all of the edits you’ve done up until that point.

I did this the other day after an hour of working on a vocal track.

2) Price

Frankly, this plug-in, especially the Studio version, is quite expensive.

The Studio version Melodyne costs more than the entire Logic Pro X software itself, which is really saying something.

On the other hand, though, the capabilities of this plug-in are quite extensive and it’s really a game-changer in terms of what it allows you to do.

3) Not Many Tutorials Online

While there are some tutorials on how to use this plug-in on the internet, there certainly aren’t hundreds of them.

Don’t worry though, as I use this software more and more, I’m going to be producing all kinds of tutorials, articles, and YouTube videos to help you learn how to use it as well.

So you don’t have to worry about being left out in the cold.

YouTube Video

Melodyne 4 - The Best Pitch Correction (Autotune) Plug-In For Garageband


All-in-all, I would say that Melodyne 4 Studio is definitely worth the money if you’re serious about music production and recording. The useful features of this software/plug-in really can’t be emphasized enough.

If you’re on a budget, grab the Editor version, but if you want to go all out, pick up the Studio version instead.

Andrew Siemon is the principal creator of, a website dedicated to all things music, including music production, music theory, recording, and how to use the most popular DAWs. Starting out as a metal guitarist, Andrew has since moved into other areas of music production including hip-hop and fusion

Leave a Comment